Thursday, March 22, 2012

An Open Letter to Larry Baer

Larry is the Giants Chief Operating Officer

Dear Larry,

We need to talk. It started a few years back, when Lew Wolff got it in his head that Oakland wasn’t the best home for the ballclub he’d recently purchased. The A’s play in a rundown stadium in a decrepit area of town in front of a dwindling—albeit loud and loyal—fanbase. The organization’s limited revenue stream prevents it from building a consistent winner and essentially makes them a ward of the league.

Enter San Jose. After it became abundantly clear that the City of Oakland has no earthly idea what it’s doing, and the fever dream that was Fremont faded quickly away, Northern California’s largest city was left to reap the spoils: a professional franchise in a sport that actually draws national interest. 

Sure, we have the 49ers moving in next door, but they’ll still bear the San Francisco brand. Then there are our beloved Sharks, who play in a league without a decent TV contract; the Earthquakes, who play the wrong sport; and the Sabercats, who ... aren’t really worth mentioning.

Major League Baseball will always be just that: Major League. And San Jose deserves a taste of Major League action. But you just won’t let us have nice things, will you, Larry?

I’m a third-generation Giants fan. My roots stretch back to the Polo Grounds. I was going to see the Orange and Black 12 years before you and your golfing buddies saved the franchise from exile to Tampa Bay. I was there for the ‘87 NLCS and both takes on Game Three of the ‘89 Series. I was there for the last season at the ‘Stick and the beginning of a new era at the Cove. 

Prior to the 2010 season, I fulfilled a lifelong dream and became a Season Ticket Holder. I was rewarded with the most glorious season of my life.

Earlier that year, the citizens of San José were treated to a poll, ostensibly funded by the San Jose Giants, your minor league affiliate. Residents were asked if they would support a new Downtown baseball stadium if it meant directing resources away from core city services like cops and firefighters.

Of course, nothing could be further from the truth, but that’s the idea behind a “push” poll. You know the answer you’re looking for, and you push the respondent there. It’s a common piece of political chicanery. Only this time, for me, it was personal.

That’s because the poll was actually funded by you and your golfing buddies. The same guys who 20 years ago saved my favorite team from leaving the Bay Area alone to the A’s were now spending oodles of dollars and miles of print to force the A’s out of the very same market. My hometown was caught in the crossfire.

Two years later, you’re still beating the same dead horse, touting your “territorial rights” over Santa Clara County as if we’ve been colonized by millionaire San Francisco lawyers in tailored suits.

What’s it gonna take to call off the siege, Larry? A few more dollars in your bank account? Your own island somewhere in the South Pacific? As Bud Fox famously asked Gordon Gekko: “How much is enough?”

I wish I could help you out, but I just cut a check to reserve my seat at AT&T for the 2012 season, so I’m a little short right now. It makes me wonder how many of those hard-earned dollars you’re going to spend in your quest to prevent San Jose from becoming a Major League City. And it makes me question why I keep contributing to the cause.


Peter Allen originally posted this letter on San Jose Inside and gave Baseball San Jose permission to post it on our blog.  


  1. Great letter, the Giants have been playing dirty pool to protect their "territory." In my opinion the Giants should have forfeited any rights to San Jose when they chose to move farther away to China Basin rather than down to the South Bay.

  2. Unimpressed. As a long time Oakland A's fan I am not a fan of any move to San Jose. It's a miracle that Lew Wolff has not destroyed the franchised by continuing to howl and hoot about how Oakland is "hopeless" and San Jose is the only chance. If he could get it into his head to actually invest in the Athletics, a move would not only be unnecessary, but absurd. If it weren't for miserly Lew Wolff, the A's would still be drawing over 2 million and might even have a Championship

  3. Oakland can't even keep a grocery store, move the A's anywhere in the bay area but Richmond, Vallejo and Oakland.

  4. Totally agree with above post ^^^^.
    Just sell the team, Lew. We know money is very important to you, and you and Fisher will profit bigtime on a sale. There's 2, possibly 3 interested groups who would love to buy the A's and make it work in Oakland. You don't want to make it work in Oakland and that's a shame.

  5. Great letter! And from a Giants fan in San Jose no doubt, not even an A's fan!
    Being a San Jose native myself, and as an Oakland A's season ticket holder, I have this argument everyday with Giants fans. Most of them saying what Mr. Larry Baer thinks, that they will lose some fans if the A's move to San Jose. Loyal Giants fans will not run out to become A's fans if they move. Plus when the A's move Giants will gain some east bay support in my opinion.
    I also disagree with the post about staying in Oakland or Lew Wolff selling the team. Oakland has no plans to keep the A's, nor can they, they are broke and Oakland is a city on the decline. If they can get anyone to show up to the run down venue they call a stadium the talk of moving would not be an issue.
    San Jose deserves a MLB team, the Giants tried to get to the South Bay, and never made it. So lets keep the rivalry alive and give the A's the new stadium in San Jose.


Thank you for commenting, your post will appear as soon as it is approved.